Yeah, I think a lot of the frustration and worry is just because this is so confusing and the mod hasn't been clear at all.
Is the problem with ALL post-CATWS prompts that don't have rape scenes, or just the ones where trash is barely a factor?
Does the 2:1 ratio mentioned refer to ratio of recovery to non-recovery prompts, or on-topic recovery to off-topic recovery?
Are we supposed to dial it back by making sure aftermath prompts are trashy enough, therefore cutting down on barely-on-topic stuff, or by posting fewer of those prompts no matter how on-topic they are?
Because I'm hoping trashmod meant that too many recovery prompts are barely on-topic and we need to be more careful about that, but their comments are vague enough it could also be interpreted to mean that all aftermath trash is now a problem for the meme and we need to limit even our trashiest, most relevant recovery ideas. There are obviously a lot of people on both sides of the argument who don't know for sure which way to read it. This uncertainty is fueling the wank.
Trashmod, we really need you to come back and clarify.
Re: "Recovery" prompts - TRASHMOD
Is the problem with ALL post-CATWS prompts that don't have rape scenes, or just the ones where trash is barely a factor?
Does the 2:1 ratio mentioned refer to ratio of recovery to non-recovery prompts, or on-topic recovery to off-topic recovery?
Are we supposed to dial it back by making sure aftermath prompts are trashy enough, therefore cutting down on barely-on-topic stuff, or by posting fewer of those prompts no matter how on-topic they are?
Because I'm hoping trashmod meant that too many recovery prompts are barely on-topic and we need to be more careful about that, but their comments are vague enough it could also be interpreted to mean that all aftermath trash is now a problem for the meme and we need to limit even our trashiest, most relevant recovery ideas. There are obviously a lot of people on both sides of the argument who don't know for sure which way to read it. This uncertainty is fueling the wank.
Trashmod, we really need you to come back and clarify.